Big printer firms are accused of ‘squeezing ever-increasing amounts of cash from the bad consumer’
It’s a busy morning at Cartridge World inside Aylesbury, piece of the chain of virtually 210 outlets over the UK which sell branded plus refilled printer cartridges. It’s a thriving company. The store has watched turnover double inside the previous five years.
But shop owner Martin Dyckhoff states shoppers come to him time plus again with all the same complaint: the branded inkjet cartridges they have purchased run from ink too fast.
The sky-high cost of printer ink – measure for measure higher priced than classic champagne – has been effectively recorded. Less well-known is that the amount of ink inside the average cartridge has shrunk dramatically. “Newer cartridges contain a fraction of the ink a synonymous product contained a decade ago,” Dyckhoff states. “The amount is minuscule.”
For illustration, the Epson T032 color cartridge (introduced inside 2002) is the same size because the Epson color T089 (introduced inside 2008). However the T032 contains 16ml of ink as well as the T089 contains simply 3.5ml of ink. It’s a synonymous story with Hewlett Packard (HP) cartridges. A decade ago, the best-selling HP cartridge had 42ml of ink plus sold for regarding £20. Today, the standard printer cartridges created by HP will contain because small because 5ml of ink yet market for about £13.
Cut open a HP inkjet cartridge plus you will find what exactly is going about. The size of the sponges inside, that hold the ink, have slowly reduced over time. The rest of the cartridge is today just clear area. In Epson cartridges, meanwhile, the ink tank has been systematically reduced inside size.
“The approach has been to nudge the customer towards a excellent frequency of purchases,” claims David Connett, editor of The Recycler, a trade magazine covering the remanufacturing industry. “The big printer producers have reduced the amount of ink inside a cartridge, encrypted the chip technologies, plus utilized aggressive advertising methods to discourage refills.”
Chris Brooks, technical director of industry group the UK Cartridge Remanufacturers Association, is a bit more forthright: “The big printer firms do all they could to squeeze ever-increasing amounts of cash from the bad customer inside exchange for less ink.”
Worst value, state the specialists, are the color cartridges. All 3 leading players, including Canon, market single tri-colour cartridges – cyan, magenta plus yellow – usually with lower than 2ml of ink per color. “They’re rather bad value considering whenever among the 3 colors runs out the whole cartridge stops functioning,” Dyckhoff states. “We constantly suggest folks purchase a printer with a separate cartridge for every color.”
The shrinking amount of ink inside cartridges has enabled producers to provide a great new product – called “XL” (extra large) nevertheless virtually the same size because the standard cartridge. For instance, HP makes the HP300, that contains 5ml of black ink plus sells for regarding £13. It furthermore makes the HP300XL, that has more ink – regarding 16ml – plus sells for about £20-£25. However both are almost identical inside size. Indeed, certain makers’ “XL” cartridges could contain less ink than standard cartridges issued a several years ago.
XL cartridges are an “insult” to the customer, claims Patrick Stead of cartridge recycler Environmental Organization Products: “HP sells half-full cartridges, then sticks an ‘XL’ about, fills them up, plus sells them for more funds. The difference inside production fees is pennies. It’s a shocking rip-off.”
The printer firms dispute which they are squeezing customers to ramp up income. “Focusing about any single element like the point of buy, the up-front expense of the cartridge or printer, the expense per page, or the millilitres of ink inside a provided cartridge is not an exact method to measure the expense of printing,” HP mentioned inside a statement. It claims customers could focus found on the expense per page of printing. It claims which about its Officejet Pro models, ink fees about a per-page basis have been maintained at the same degrees because 2009.
Epson, meanwhile, argues which print heads are better compared with 10 years ago due to advances inside technologies. “These are generally able to provide a better quantity of pages with an equal amount of ink,” the organization mentioned inside a statement.
Of the leading producers, Canon has been the minimum aggressive inside its ink reduction, yet volumes have nevertheless shrunk. Its latest PGI-525BK inkjet cartridge, for illustration, contains 19ml of ink compared with its 26ml BCI-3BK issued inside 2005. The business has furthermore introduced standard plus XL cartridges.
Critics accept there were improvements inside development plus contemporary print heads are better. “But these improvements cannot justify a five-fold decrease inside the amount of ink inside a cartridge,” Brooks claims. “The expense of printer ink is the lowest it’s ever been, a some euros for a litre. Many cartridges cost lower than 50p to create. The mark-up is massive. The customer is paying more pro-rata now than a decade ago for cartridges containing pretty small ink.”
There is an intense battle between producers (HP, Epson plus Canon) plus “remanufacturers”, represented by Brooks, that refill cartridges to market at a discount. Remanufacturers have grabbed a 3rd of UK sales, simultaneously because counterfeit cartridges from China are flooding into the nation.
In addition, aggressive competition from modern entrants including Kodak, that threw itself into the marketplace inside the mid-2000s providing inexpensive plastic printers plus even cheaper cartridges, has consumed into their bottom line. (Kodak mentioned last year it was pulling from the inkjet marketplace.)
“The big 3 have enjoyed a year-on-year erosion of their marketplace share,” Brooks claims. “They had to do anything drastic.”
The reaction has been to market cheaper printers plus recoup the income about low-ink cartridges, that customers need to substitute more frequently. A decade ago, the average home printer expense upwards of £150, however, now they retail for because small because £30.
Many fresh printers come with “start-up” cartridges which contain tiny amounts of ink thus the owner has to purchase hot cartridges virtually instantly. Others have embedded development to block inexpensive refills. “The logic is easy,” Stead states. “Once a customer purchases a HP printer they need to purchase HP cartridges, regardless what they cost.”
Personal finance plus funds information, analysis plus comment | guardian.co.uk
There are no comments yet. Why not be the first to speak your mind.